Break London’s domination of state spending to level up Britain
Reaction
Here’s a weird thing. There are certain types of government spending which do more than others to get a local economy moving.
Like better transport, to join up places and connect people to new opportunities. Housing infrastructure to open up new development and more homes. Research and development (R&D) spending to spur the creation of new businesses and help existing firms become more high-tech. Culture spending, to make a place a magnet for skilled people.
But the weird thing is that for decades we have we spent more on these productivity-raising things in areas that are already the most productive, but less in the places that most need it.
In a report I have out today for Onward we reveal the full, surprising extent of the problem.
Per head, London receives nearly twice the UK average R&D spending, nearly three times as much capital funding for transport as the rest of England. It gets five times as much financial support for affordable housing as the rest of England, and enjoys nearly five times the as much spending on culture as the rest of England.
It’s a big problem for Boris Johnson’s plan to “level up” poorer areas.
In each case the reasons why officials have maintained this pattern of spending over the years varies. And if we understand the rationale, we can figure out how to change it, while benefitting the economy overall.
For example, when it comes to R&D spending, officials are focussed on funding lots of “pure”, early stage research in universities. Compared to places in Asia or the US, we don’t spend so much on industrial R&D, outside universities.
To stereotype a bit, compared to China, we’re investing lots on exploring the nature of the early universe and so on, and less on trying to make a car part 20% cheaper or greener.
This approach has meant more and more spending is focussed on a small number of leading universities. The share of the core research budget spent in just three cities, Oxford, Cambridge and London, rose from 42% in 2003 to 46% in 2018.
That’s nearly half our spending in just three lucky cities.
Business spending on R&D is much more balanced across the country. The private sector spends roughly as much as the government in London. But five times more than government in the West Midlands.
If we change the paradigm, and make our R&D spending more industrially focussed, that would be a good thing in itself. But it would also make for a fairer balance of spending across the country.
The story in housing is different again. London gets half the total budget for social housing devolved to it. The thought is simply that London is an expensive place to live. Supporting housing there is widely regarded as “obviously” the right thing to do.
But hang on a minute. London already has more social housing than the rest of the country: 22.6% of homes in London, compared to 17.1% in the rest of England. London doesn’t have half the people on waiting lists in England – it has a fifth.
For the price of one council house in an expensive area like London you can build two up north. It’s not obvious that just having expensive housing should mean London scoops half the money.
In transport there are several reasons the richest areas get the most money.
It’s partly capacity: London has a powerful devolved government, while in much of the country councils don’t even have the money to work up schemes to bid for. It is partly about the way we evaluate schemes.
It’s partly because we spend a lot on rail, which is big in London but a tiny share of journeys elsewhere.
And it’s partly because if you focus on narrow measures like the number of minutes saved, then funding will go mainly to areas that are currently booming and have the congestion to prove it. If, in contrast, you take a wider view of the economic benefits of a new investment, and the potential for journeys that are not taken today because transport is so poor, then areas with fewer constraints on growth (like more available land) will do better.
When it comes to culture spending, London gets half (47% of the total). There isn’t really an intellectual argument for this – it is just the continuation of a longstanding pattern. DCMS directly funds “national” institutions like the Royal Opera House, and most such institutions happen to be in London: the capital gets 90% of such spending.
If we spent more on, say, music lessons for kids, so people at the opera paid a bit more, we’d have a fairer balance of spending.
In all these types of spending there is a circular logic. We’re trying to solve problems of congestion and house prices in rich areas by throwing money at the problem. But that spending stimulates more growth, more congestion and so on. We are trying to put out a fire by pouring on petrol.
If you map the seats Boris won in his triumph last year, the centre point is on the moors just outside Sheffield. Many of the seats he won are in places that have never voted Tory before, and where people are frustrated about being overlooked. It is time to repay their trust and change the old established ways of doing things which officials have presided over for so long.
'The Observer' quotes figures from Onward's 'Breaking Blue' report which breaks down the results of the 2024 election. They use the figures to make a case for what the next Tory leader need to prioritise.
'Conservative Home' mentions Onward's 'The British Entrepreneur' report. The article quotes Onward's findings that British workers are becoming “unusually risk-averse” when it comes to setting up their own business.
Onward's 'Capital Issues' report is quoted in a 'Financial Times' article on AIM markets and UK small-cap stocks.
'The Financial Times' covers Onward's 'Capital Issue' report which calls for the abolition of London's AIM markets.
A 'CityAM' article about abolishing London's AIM markets quotes Onward's 'Capital Issues' report.
'CityAM' quotes Onward's 'Capital Issues' report, which calls for the immediate abolition of London's AIM market.
'Share Talk' cites Onward's 'Capital Issues' paper, which calls for an urgent scrapping of London's AIM market.
'The Independent' quotes an article written for Onward by Rt Hon Jesse Norman MP about the future of the Conservative party in the next election.
In their Monday round-up, 'Politico' covers a speech made by Rt Hon James Cleverly at an Onward event.
'Politics' covers a speech made by Rt Hon James Cleverly MP at Onward's conference event.
'Politics' website cites Onward's findings that the Conservative party cannot afford to play to Reform switchers after the general election.
'UnHerd' quotes Onward's 'Breaking Blue' report about the future of the Conservative party after the general election.
'The Sun' quotes Onward's 'Breaking Blue' report in its article about the future of the Conservative party after the 2024 general election.
This Telegraph article covers Robert Jenrick's speech about the future of the Conservative party. The article quotes Onward's 'Breaking Blue' report outlining why the Conservatives lost the last election.
'The Times' uses polling data from Onward's 'Breaking Blue' report in its coverage of the election betting scandal, specifically in relation to how scandals in British politics have affected the electorate.
Andrew Griffith MP retweets Onward's 'Igniting Innovation' report. He argues that we cannot take a ‘regulate-first, fret-later’ approach to technology regulation, and points to the report as a clear summary of the problem and proposed solutions.
Policy Director of the thinktank 'Reform' praises Onward's 'Igniting Innovation' report for addressing how technology regulation is harming innovation
'CityAM' echoes Onward's recommended tech regulation reforms in our latest 'Igniting Innovation' report.
Nick Timothy MP CBE, co-author of Onward's 'A Conservative Economy' report, writes a piece for 'The Telegraph' on the future of Conservative economic thinking.
'The Spectator' covers Onward's radical reform of property taxation outlined in the 'Fairer Property Tax' report.
'The Yorkshire Post' cites Onward's findings that mayors should create development corps to aid levelling up.
George Freeman MP and the Onward team have written a substack outlining the proposals in the new 'Future Frontiers' report.
'The Telegraph' covers Onward's policy recommendations to reform property tax to make the system fairer. They show that Onward's recommendations are supported across the political spectrum.
The UK's universities are struggling to capitalize on their world-class research. 'Global Venturing' covers Onward's policy recommendations that the government should create a university fund accelerator to boost spinouts from universities.
'The Times' covers the findings in Onward's 'Venturing Out' report that universities are failing to capitalize on world-class research and what can be done to rectify the problem.
'Local Gov' website discusses Onward's policy recommendations that support in low council tax areas should be reduced to raise an extra £600m which could be used to make the system fairer.
'The Municipal Journal' covers the policy recommendations made in Onward's 'A Fairer Property Tax' report. The report argues that the government should reduce support where council tax is low to make the system fairer.
'Business Green' quotes Onward's published polling data that over a third of UK drivers buying a new car this year want to go electric.
'iNews' covers Onward's policy recommendations that VAT on electricity should be cut in order to boost electric vehicle adoption.
'The Guardian' discusses Onward's 'A Fairer Property Tax' report arguing for a wealth tax on housing.
'iNews' echoes Onward's policy recommendations that the government should cut VAT on electricity for EVs to aid the public in making the transition to electric cars.
'GB News' echoes Onward's call that Britain needs a New Deal for Parents, focusing on Onward's policy recommendations that the two-child benefit cap should be scrapped.
'Public Finance' discusses Onward's policy recommendations that the two-child benefit cap should be scrapped.
'The New Stateman' quotes Onward's 'Age of Alienation' report in its discussion on the loneliness epidemic currently facing our young people.
'The Times' echoes Onward's warnings in its 'Future Frontiers' report that major reforms are needed if the UK is to be able to capitalize on emerging technologies.
'The Mirror' supports Onward's policy recommendations that the two-child benefit limit should be scrapped.
'The Spectator' references Onward's 'New Deal for Parents' report and discusses whether the 'motherhood penalty' is leading to the UK's declining birth rates.
'The Telegraph' echoes Onward's policy recommendations in the 'New Deal for Parents' report that couples should received a £5k tax break so that they can afford to have children.
'Politico' mentions Onward's new report 'A New Deal for Parents' in their weekly round-up.
'The Times' covers Onward's 'New Deal for Parents' report, describing how the 'motherhood penalty' is driving women to have fewer children.
'The Daily Mail' covers Onward's 'New Deal for Parents' report, specifically on the concept of the 'motherhood penalty'.
The Government announce a consultation on operational reforms to the Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project, which was recommended by Onward's report, 'Wired for Success'.
'The Guardian' quotes Onward's 'Breaking Blue' report, discussing the findings that former Conservative supporters who opted for Reform or the Lib Dems in the general election had common characteristics, including skepticism towards Keir Starmer and worries about immigration.
'iNews' quotes Onward's 'Breaking Blue' report to discuss how the Tories need to position themselves ahead of their general election defeat.
Allan Nixon, head of science and technology at Onward, co-writes a piece in 'Research Professional News' about the need to prioritise an ambitious vision for science policy.
Deputy Chief Executive at Onward, Adam Hawksbee, writes an essay for the UPP Foundation about university philanthropy.
'Bloomberg' mentions Onward's 'A Conservative Economy' report in the context of Labour's polling ahead of the general election.
'The Independent' reports on a speech made by Robert Jenrick on manufacturing at Onward's under-35s only event in March this year.
Project Director, Gavin Rice, writes in 'Conservative Home' about how Britain needs an industrial strategy that supports manufacturing as well as innovation.
'The National News' mentions Onward's 2023 report which states that Clacton ranks among the top 1% of most deprived neighborhoods in England, in the context of Nigel Farage's prospects in the upcoming general election.
'The Municipal Journal' quotes Onward's report on the potential of mayoral devolution.
An article in 'The Mirror' uses figures from Onward's 'Smiles All Round' report about the dental crisis.
Onward Director, Sebastian Payne, appears on an episode of 'Cross Questions'.
An article in 'CityAM' cites Onward's suggestion that a British data library would allow startups and scientists to easily access the data needed to build AI models, attracting talent and investment to Britain.
Head of the 'New Deal for Parents' programme, Phoebe Arslanagić-Little, writes in 'Conservative Home' about how the Conservative manifesto needs to make a generous offer to parents.
'The Independent' covers Onward's findings that the apprenticeship levy risks causing a further sharp decline in the number of apprenticeship starts.
'The Times' echoes Onward's 'Great British National Service' report on what National Service could look like in the UK.
'The Spectator Australia' cites Onward's report 'Trading Places' to make the case that international student caps should be more stringent.
'New Philanthropy Capital' quotes Onward's 'Giving Back Better' report in their report on how civil society should be a key partner in delivering government commitments.
The Shropshire Star reports on Onward's findings that the new flexibility in the apprenticeship levy risks causing a sharp decline in the number of apprenticeship starts.
'The Telegraph' use figures from Onward's 'Great British National Service' report to highlight the potential benefits of National Service.
'Sky News' mention Onward's 'Great British National Service' report to outline what national service in the UK could look like.
'Bloomberg' mentions Onward's 'Great British National Service' report to make a case for UK national service.
'The Times' covers Onward's report 'Back to Basics' on neighbourhood policing.
'The Spectator' mentions Onward's report 'Great British National Service'.
'The Times' quotes from Onward's report 'Great British National Service'.
Onward Director, Gavin Rice, writes about reindustrializing Britain in 'The Critic'.
'The Sun' covers Onward's 'Off Course' report.
Onward's 'A Conservative Economy' report is cited in a 'Fair Comment' about wealth inequality.
Onward Deputy Director Adam Hawksbee talks to iNews about 'Levelling Up'.
Onward's Deputy Director, Adam Hawksbee, and researcher Shivani Menon discuss philanthropy in 'The New Statesman'. Read the article here.
Onward's 'Off Course' report is cited in an article in 'Research Professional News'.
'The Yorkshire Post' cites Onward's 'Smiles All Round' report.
This week’s 'New Economy Brief' unpacks Onward's 'A Conservative Economy' report.
Onward's report, 'A Conservative Economy', is covered in 'Times Higher Education'.
Onward's report 'Smiles All Round' is covered in 'Dentistry'.
'CityAM' mentions Onward's call for a British Library for Data from our upcoming paper, 'Future Frontiers'.
Onward's report 'Smiles All Round' is covered in 'The Yorkshire Post'.
Onward's report 'Smiles All Round' is covered in 'The Mirror'.
Onward's 'Smiles All Round' report is covered in 'The Telegraph'
Nick Timothy MP quotes his co-authored Onward report, 'A Conservative Economy', in 'The Daily Telegraph'
Onward Director Sebastian Payne wrote in the i about what should be in the Budget next week.
Tories pray for a miracle after a lackluster budget
Onward's Deputy Director Adam Hawksbee is quoted in Politico discussing the budget and praising Hunt's prioritisation of working families.
Deputy Director Adam Hawksbee made the case for more neighbourhood policing in The New Statesman.
Onward's Deputy Director, Adam Hawksbee outlines how we can avoid another cost of living crisis in City AM.
Birthrate in UK falls to record low as campaigners say ‘procreation a luxury
The Guardian quotes Head of the New Deal for Parents Phoebe Arslanagić-Little discussing how the UK is pricing people out of parenthood.
Onward's Director Sebastian Payne discusses the need for a national neighbourhood policing uplift across the UK in the i.
Onward's Director Sebastian Payne discusses the impact that threats of violence towards MPs can have on democracy in the i.
Raise council tax to fix policing, says think tank
The Telegraph discusses Onward's Back to Basics report that urged the Government to scrap the current £13 cap on council tax increases to allow local authorities to support further policing.
Raise taxes by 45p a week to fund thousands of community police, think tank urges
The Yorkshire Post covered Onward's Back to Basics plan to rebuild local policing across England and Wales.
Home Secretary welcomes the idea of an extra 19,000 bobbies on the beat to restore neighbourhood policing
Onward's report 'Back to Basics' is highlighted in a Daily Mail article on restoring neighbourhood policing.